Skip to main content
Submitted by PatientsEngage on 24 November 2016

Who should have a Hip or Knee Replacement Surgery and what are the alternatives available? Dr Shital Raval suggests factors to help you make a decision. 

Let us evaluate the various options available and the factors to consider.

Arthroplasty

Total hip replacement surgery is also known as Total Hip Arthroplasty while a knee replacement surgery is called Knee Arthroplasty (can be partial or total).

Both are common and effective procedures for hip and knee arthritis.

These are elective procedures that are chosen by the patient. Joint replacement surgery can improve joint function, lifestyle and also help reduce pain.

Remember, such elective surgeries can be done at any time and patients should not be pressured to undergo it.

Who should consider it!

  • Patients who have tried all non-operative treatments* with minimal relief.
  • Patients with continual groin or knee pain due to arthritis.
  • Patients with grinding bones or friction and cartilage thinning.
  • Instability/loosening of the joint causing falls.
  • Patients who have difficulty in daily life with walking, climbing or bending.
  • Patients who are unable to sleep due to the intense pain.

Who should avoid getting it done!

  • Patients with mild or early arthritis, surgery is not recommended. Best to try all other avenues of treatment first.
  • Although infection with hip replacement is rare, if there are any indications of infection, surgery will be postponed.
  • Surgery can temporarily worsen any underlying heart or lung conditions, so a thorough assessment of the patient’s ability to recover is required.
  • People with muscle weakness disorders such as Parkinson’s Disease are less suitable candidates because they have lesser chance of recovery.
  • Patients with blood clotting disorders are advised to be very cautious and avoid risky surgeries.

*Non-operative treatment methods

These include anti-inflammatory medications, weight loss, physical therapy, steroid injections, heel wedges, unloader braces, prolotherapy or injections of the hyaluronic acid gel. 

Complimentary therapies such as acupuncture, diet, yoga, meditation, etc. are also found to be beneficial. Cutting edge treatment can now include stem cell replacement in the knee to promote cartilage growth.

Osteotomy

Another surgical alternative to joint replacement is Osteotomy. This involves slicing and realigning the bone such that the weight is shifted from the damaged to healthier bone surface. This is not commonly done anymore due to poor results compared to Arthroplasty.

Download our e-book on 20 Tips on Arthritis Management

Stories

  • An elderly man on the floor, being assisted by a woman, with his cane on the floor next to him and text overlay on blue strip Causes of Falls in Elderly
    Causes of Falls in Older Adults
    The demographic of the world's population is shifting towards older age groups. The prevalence of falls and associated injuries and morbidity is on the rise, posing a significant global challenge. Knowing the causes of falls in elderly can help create awareness and aid prevention. Let’s find out a bit more about the causes of falls in elderly.  Professor Bernard Isaacs, a giant in geriatric medicine said, ‘It takes a child one year to acquire independent movement and ten years to acquire…
  • Picture of the writer, an elderly woman with Rheumatoid arthritis and Long covid sitting in front of a window and the text overlay Long Covid Experience
    Living With The Disequilibrium of Long Covid
    74 year old Jacqueline Colaco, who has lived with Rheumatoid Arthritis for many years, shares her experience of dealing with Covid, Long Covid, dry eyes, hearing loss, fatigue and its impact on her overall health and quality of life. My encounter with the Covid delta strain manifested one morning in January 2022, when I experienced acute weakness and a mighty cough. The nurse on duty at the Senior Citizen Home where I reside, immediately referred to my doctor, who advised immediate…
  • An elderly gentleman sitting on a sofa and holding his knee. Overlay of text Osteoporosis vs Osteoarthritis
    Difference Between Osteoarthritis And Osteoporosis
    Many people often confuse osteoporosis with osteoarthritis, commonly known as arthritis. The terms may be used interchangeably quite often; however, they are not even distant cousins. Let us understand the differences and how each of these needs to be managed. Osteoporosis occurs when the bones in our body lose mineral density and become thin and brittle. They cannot bear normal weight and thus break easily. Osteoarthritis is a disease of wear and tear of not just the bone but the surrounding…
  • Woman standing on the beach with a cane in hand and overlay of text in white on purple background - I lost my sight, not my vision, Rare neuro condition experience
    Learn About Your Condition To Manage It Better
    Kavya Poornima Balajepalli lost her eyesight at 21 after a brief period of intense headaches due to Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension (IIH), a rare neurological disorder. Here she talks about her struggles after loss of vision, how she manages her condition and how she became an IIH warrior to create awareness about the disease. Please could you tell us a bit about your background. I am based in Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh. I did my graduation in architecture from the University of Mumbai…
  • An elderly woman exercising using resistance bands and text overlay that says exercise for osteoporosis
    ऑस्टियोपोरोसिस के लिए सही व्यायाम
    ऑस्टियोपोरोसिस (कमजोर हड्डियाँ, अस्थिसुषिरता, अस्थिसुविरता) से पीड़ित व्यक्तियों के लिए सही व्यायाम गति की बहाली, कार्यात्मक गतिशीलता के रखरखाव, ताकत और चोट से बचाने में मदद करता है। इस लेख में फिजियोथेरेपिस्ट नेहा सेठिया व्यायाम के लिए विस्तार में इन मुद्दों को संबोधित करता है। इसे बुकमार्क करें। ऑस्टियोपोरोसिस के एक केस का वर्णन एक 62 वर्षीय महिला क्लिनिक एक महीने से कमर दर्द की शिकायत के साथ आई थीं। उसे बिस्तर पर करवट लेने में, एक घंटे से अधिक समय तक बैठने में और आधे घंटे से अधिक समय तक खड़े…
  • Side view of a woman with short hair and rheumatoid arthritis holding her hands together
    मैं रूमेटॉइड आर्थ्राइटिस को सक्रिय रूप से कैसे प्रबंधित करती हूं
    मुंबई की 76 वर्षीय राशने दुबाश को दो दशकों से अधिक समय से रूमेटॉइड आर्थ्राइटिस है, और वे इस लेख में इस के साथ अपनी यात्रा साझा करती हैं। वे अपने लक्षणों के बारे में बात करती हैं और बताती हैं कि वे अपने स्वास्थ्य का प्रबंधन कैसे करती हैं और उन्होंने इस दौरान क्या सीखा। राशने दुबाश एक ऊर्जावान जीवंत व्यक्ति हैं जो नहीं चाहती हैं कि कोई भी बीमारी उनकी जीवनशैली पर अंकुश लगाए। वे सक्रिय रहती हैं, सेवानिवृत्त होने से इनकार करती हैं और जिंदगी से प्यार करती हैं। वे एक स्कूल में प्रशासक के रूप…
  • Side view of a woman with short hair and rheumatoid arthritis holding her hands together
    How I Proactively Manage Rheumatoid Arthritis
    Rashne Dubash, 76 year old from Mumbai shares her journey of living with Rheumatoid Arthritis for over two decades. She talks about her symptoms, how she manages her health and the lessons learnt. Rashne Dubash is an energetic vibrant person who does not want any disease to curb her lifestyle. She continues to be active, refuses to retire and loves her life. She used to work as an administrator for a school and now works for a design firm. Please tell us a bit about your condition? I have…
  • Family Support And Faith Helped Me Through Ankylosing Spondylitis
    Despite a family history of Ankylosing Spondylitis, it took 2 years for Amit Choudhari to get a diagnosis of Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS). Luckily despite experiencing pain and attacks, the treatment and medication prevented joint fusions. He talks of how AS affects his social, employment and lifestyle choices and how faith and family support help him cope with the condition.  Please tell us a bit about your condition I have been suffering from Ankylosing Spondylitis (HLA B-27 Positive.)…
  • Courage And A Positive Attitude Help Fight Back Ankylosing Spondylitis
    Ramesh B. Choudhari, 64 from Nagpur was not only afflicted with Ankylosing Spondylitis from a young age, but was diagnosed very late which led to fusion of his joints and consequent surgeries. But that did not stop him from working, and leading a normal life to the best of his abilities. Please tell us a bit about your condition I have been suffering from Ankylosing Spondylitis (AS) since 1972 ( my age was 14 yrs then) , but I was only correctly diagnosed in as late as 1997. I have had multiple…
  • Headshot of a man in a purple shirt framed in blue background
    "Supporting Ankylosing Spondylitis Patients Is My Mission"
    Bhushan Ghate, 45 of Nagpur has been suffering from Ankylosing spondylitis, an inflammatory disease that can cause bones in the spine to fuse, from the early age of 12. Delayed diagnosis worsened the condition for which he is completely home bound now. He runs patient support groups and helps others with a similar condition in his own way. Challenges in Diagnosis I am a good example of delayed diagnosis. When I first felt the symptoms of Ankylosing Spondylitis, it was in 1988-89, when I was…