Skip to main content
Submitted by PatientsEngage on 28 October 2016

And other questions on menopause answered by Dr. Usha Saraiya,  Consultant Obstetrician – Gynaecologist at Breach Candy, Cumballa Hill Hospital & Saifee Hospital. She reiterates - Preventive actions helps to prevent Osteoporosis, diabetes & heart disease. 

1.   What is the average age of menopause in India?

It is between 45 years to 50 years. In India it is said to be earlier say from 42 years to 47 years. But women who are not educated do not tell their age correctly. So it may not be very reliable.

2.    What are the common complaints/symptoms that you see in your menopausal patients.

Common complaints are mood swings. They cannot control their emotions well. They cry easily & get very angry without much provocation. They realise it themselves & regret it afterwards. Many also are disturbed by hot flashes. Some notice that there is a lack of libido & are no longer interested in sex life. Urinary frequency & repeated attacks of urinary tract infection are also a sign of early menopause.

3.    How do you usually deal with their complaints/ symptoms.

Most sympathetically, reassure them that it is a passing phase & that they have to learn to cope with it. Symptomatic treatment has to be given.

4.    At what stage should they seek your medical attention with these symptoms?

As early as possible. Benefits are more when treated at an early stage.

5.    Do you recommend any particular diet for them?

Not a particular diet but we do take a history of the diet & recommend some changes

6.    Do you enrol the help of a dietician/nutritionist?

Sometimes, especially in overweight women.

7.    How about any specific exercises or forms of workout?

Regular exercise is always suggested. Going for a walk is something anyone can do.

8.    Are relaxation techniques such as yoga or meditation recommended?

Yoga and meditation help a lot in an over anxious patient.

9.    How many patients experience psychological symptoms or depression?

About 5% of women admit to being depressed or have psychological problems. During the consultation you can get an idea of these patterns.

10.   Which patients are potential candidates for HRT?

Potential candidates are those of surgical menopause. When ovaries are removed surgically there is a sudden loss of hormones & temporary replacement therapy is required. It is also considered when symptoms are severe & psychological changes are obvious.

11.   What are the common side-effects of HRT and how do you deal with them?

HRT has to be given under continuous medical supervision & after doing all the tests. It is a lot of responsibility for the gynaecologists. Patients have to cooperate & come for regular checkups.

12.   Do you suggest Psychiatry help for women who experience depression on HRT?

Yes. HRT cannot cure depression. We work with the Psychiatrist.

13.   What medications are they usually prescribed?

In addition to HRT, antipsychotic & anti depressant medicines are prescribed. Once again close follow up is mandatory.

14.   Any new medicines in the market for menopause, hormonal or otherwise?

Estradiol Valearate is the new estrogen molecule found to be suitable for menopause. Isoflavones have always been advised as they are plant estrogens & are safe. Nowadays they are recommended for prolonged period. Estrogen patches are safer because they bypass the liver. Any subcutaneous route if available may be recommended.

15.   Would you prescribe them?

Yes, after seeing the trials & the reports of trials from Indian patients.

16.   What is the best advice to women who are perimenopausal? If and what lifestyle changes would you recommend?

Pre & Perimenopausal is the best time for preventive measures. A thorough check up at around 40 years of age is recommended. Preventive actions helps to prevent Osteoporosis, diabetes & heart disease. Lifestyle changes if made at this stage will ensure a long life & healthy life. Preventive strategies have to be instituted before the disease damages the organs. The old proverb “A stitch in time saves nine” is very appropriate here.

Dr. Usha B. Saraiya, MD DGO FIAC FICS FICOG FRCOG (UK), is a Consultant Obstetrician – Gynaecologist at Breach Candy, Cumballa Hill Hospital & Saifee Hospital, Vice President – Central Asia Medical Women’s International Association, Chairman, Indian College of Obstetrician & Gynaecologist (2006-2009) 

Stories

  • Stock pic showing Knee Pain
    जीवन की गति धीमी करने से स्वास्थ्य में सुधार: एक अनुभव
    काजल* सक्रिय  रहती थीं और अपनी जीवनशैली को लेकर सावधान थीं। जब उनका बेवजह  वजन कम होने लगा और घुटने में दर्द भी होने लगा तो उन्होंने कई टेस्ट करवाए और विशेषज्ञों से मिलीं। प्राप्त सलाह और समाधानों से संतुष्ट न होने पर, काजल ने खुद समाधान खोजने के लिए विभिन्न पूरक उपचारों को सक्रिय रूप से खोजा और कुछ आश्चर्यजनक निष्कर्ष निकाले। मैं हमेशा से ही पतली और सक्रिय रही हूं। अपने माता-पिता की स्वास्थ्य समस्याओं को पहचानते हुए, जब मेरी उम्र तीस साल हुई तो मैंने जीवन शैली को अधिक स्वस्थ  …
  • Profile picture of Gita Kantawala
    मुझे दूसरी राय लेनी चाहिए थी।
    मुंबई की 72 वर्षीय गीता कांतवाला को मेनिस्कस टीयर के कारण आर्थोस्कोपी के बाद में बाएं घुटने का रिप्लेसमेंट हुआ।  वे अपनी सर्जरी की विफलता और सफलताओं और रिकवरी और रिहैबिलिटेशन (पुनर्प्राप्ति और पुनर्वास प्रक्रिया) की बात करती हैं। और दूसरे डॉक्टर से राय लेने की जरूरत है, इस पर जोर देती हैं। मुझे अप्रैल 2016 में अपने बाएं घुटने में मेनिस्कस टीयर का निदान मिला। एक दिन मेरा घुटना लॉक हो गया (एक ही पोजीशन में जकड़ गया) और मैंने जब चलने की कोशिश की तो घुटना मेरा बोझ नहीं ले पाया और मैं गिर…
  • Keep Your Bones Strong Over 50
    It is estimated that more than 200 million people across the globe suffer from osteoporosis. Approximately 30% of all postmenopausal ladies have osteoporosis. Dr S M Akerkar, consultant rheumatologist, stresses that brisk walking is one of the best and safest exercise for strengthening the bones. What is Osteoporosis? Simply speaking osteoporosis means – ‘porous’ or brittle bones. They are less dense when compared to a normal bone, hence weak and more likely to fracture. Osteoporotic fractures…
  • CKD and women's health issues
    Women’s Health Issues for Patients With Chronic Kidney Disease
    Dr Raka Kaushal, a senior nephrologist focused on various women’s issues amongst patients with Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD) in a webinar with PatientsEngage in English and Hindi. The questions raised from pregnancy complications, to hair loss, abnormal periods, menopause, oral contraceptives and more.  Here is a synopsis of the key questions addressed. Link to recording on youtube below. Each question is marked with the time stamp. 1:43 Are women with CKD more likely to have…
  • Image: Fingers pointing at a Bone Scan Image
    When To Get A Bone Scan?
    What is a Bone Scan? What do the results of the scan indicate? When do you need a Bone Scan? How often should you get a Bone Scan? We give you information that will help you discuss your options with your doctor. What is a Bone Scan  A Bone scan is done to check the bone mineral density (BMD) so as to assess strength of the bones and probability of any fractures. The scan helps identify any mild (osteopenia) or serious bone loss (osteoporosis). The most common bone density test is the DEXA…
  • Mausumi, a dark haired woman on the right with her mother, a person with dementia on the left. Mother is wearing specs and  a bindi on her forehead and you can see the blue and white sari draped around her shoulders
    Patience And Innovation Are The Most Important Attributes Of A Caregiver For Persons With Dementia
    Mausumi Ghosh from Mumbai talks about the travails of taking care of her mother, 77 who suffers from dementia in addition to other conditions like osteosporosis. My mother is an osteoporosis patient from 2003 when she underwent hip replacement operation in Mumbai. She recovered from the same very well and was mobile and independent till she met with a ‘fall’ at home in 2010 and broke her ‘femur bone’ (left leg). She got herself operated twice in Kolkata in AMRI hospital and both the times the ‘…
  • Image: Stock pic of vegetarian source s of protein - bowls of lentils and pulses, tofu, paneer, etc
    How Can A Vegetarian Get Enough Daily Protein?
    Indians, especially vegetarians often do not get adequate protein in their diet. Registered Dietician, Nutritionist and Diabetes Educator Eileen Canday guides us on how vegetarians can make sure they get enough protein in their diets. An executive member of the Indian Dietetic Association she currently works with Sir H.N. Reliance hospital in Mumbai.  1.   Why is protein important for our body? Protein is important for our body to repair tissues from the physiological wear…
  • On the left an Indian woman in a pink dress and white scarf who was over weight and on the right a trimmer version woman in a white and yellow top and black pants
    I Walk with Hand-Weights to Lose Weight and Build Health
    Kavita Behl, 53, who was diagnosed with high levels of uric acid causing excruciating pain and swelling in her feet, got back her health with a strict walking regimen and disciplined diet. Her mantra now - Be positive and Keep walking.  My problems started two years back in May 2016. I had developed swelling and pain in both my ankles and feet. The pain was so acute that I was not able to put my feet down. I had to go to a doctor. After a series of tests, I was detected with high levels of…
  • Stock pic showing Knee Pain
    Slowing Down to Speed Up Wellbeing
    Kajal* had been active and careful about her lifestyle. When she experienced weight loss and started having knee pain she went through a series of tests and specialist doctors. Not satisfied with the solutions presented, she pro-actively looked at various complementary therapies to find solutions and made some surprising findings. I’ve always been thin and active. When I hit thirty, alerted by my parents’ health problems, I switched to a healthy lifestyle. I ate wholegrain foods, healthy fats,…
  • Image: Knees and lower legs of a woman on a hospital bed after a knee replacement surgery
    Knee Replacement Post Operation Rehab Care
    Even though knee replacement operations have become more commonplace these days, one needs to be aware of the do’s and dont’s after the operation.  When the severity of a condition is such that physiotherapy for knee pain and any other conversant treatment fails, knee replacement becomes binding. Recovering from knee replacement can be highly challenging especially during the initial days. Here is a comprehensive guide on post-operative care for knee replacement so that both you and your…