Skip to main content
Submitted by PatientsEngage on 30 October 2023
An elderly gentleman sitting on a sofa and holding his knee. Overlay of text Osteoporosis vs Osteoarthritis

Many people often confuse osteoporosis with osteoarthritis, commonly known as arthritis. The terms may be used interchangeably quite often; however, they are not even distant cousins. Let us understand the differences and how each of these needs to be managed.

Osteoporosis occurs when the bones in our body lose mineral density and become thin and brittle. They cannot bear normal weight and thus break easily.

Osteoarthritis is a disease of wear and tear of not just the bone but the surrounding cartilage that leads to joint pain and limits movement.

 

OSTEOARTHRITIS(OA)

OSTEOPOROSIS

WHAT IT MEANS

Degeneration/wear and tear of joint and surrounding cartilage Loss in bone mass

WHAT IT DOES

Causes joint pain and limits movement and function of joints Causes bone loss and fractures

CAUSES

Modifiable factors:

  • Being overweight, joint strength, and joint injury/trauma

Non-Modifiable factors:

  • Genetics, ethnicity, gender (female; after age 45), aging.

Research has shown that muscle weakness can contribute to osteoarthritis and muscle wasting is a common occurrence.

  • Overactive thyroid gland (hyperthyroidism)
  • Reduced estrogen in women due to menopause or removal of uterus(hysterectomy), ovarian issues, pituitary and hypothalamus related issues, low thyroid functioning or cancer therapy and reduced testosterone in men due to testicular injuries, cancer therapy, low thyroid function, issue with the pituitary gland or hypothalamus (part of brain)
  • Pituitary gland issues like masses in the pituitary or hypopituitarism (underactive pituitary).
  • Overactive parathyroid glands (hyperparathyroidism)
  • Family history of osteoporosis
  • History of fractures/broken bones after age of 50
  • History of being underweight or having low Body mass index (BMI) <=19
  • Long-term use of high-dose steroid medications
  • Eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia
  • Heavy drinking and smoking
  • Rheumatoid arthritis
  • Coeliac disease and Crohn's disease are both autoimmune diseases that cause gluten intolerance and malabsorption of nutrients like Vitamin D which can lead to osteoporosis. They also cause the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines, calcium malabsorption, and the activation of osteoclasts(cells that breakdown bone tissue) which again lead to bone weakening and loss of density.
  • Long-term bed rest or inactive state can also lead to bone loss due to inability to perform any weight bearing activities and decreased activity of osteoblasts (bone building cells)

SYMPTOMS and SIGNS

  • Soreness or stiffness in joints such as the hip , knees or back because of inactivity or overuse
  • Crackling sound from joints on movement
  • Mild swelling or pain around the joint
  • Pain and stiffness that increases more towards the end of the day
  • Limitation of movement or stiffness that improves as the joint is mobilized
  • Insidious in the earlier stages unless one has a fracture when it’s incidentally discovered during investigations
  • Painless initially, pain may occur in later stages
  • Honeycomb sign : Under a microscope, the inside of a bone resembles a honeycomb. In osteoporosis, the bone, that forms the margins of the honeycomb, gets smaller, and the spaces between the bones grow larger. The outer margin of the bone becomes thinner.

HOW IS IT DETECTED?

  • Physical examination
  • Ultrasound of the joint
  • X-ray of the joints
  • Blood tests
  • Physical examination
  • Ultrasound
  • Bone density (BMD) testing called DEXA Scan, or dual-energy-x-ray-absorptiometry. Its shows valued as the T score.
  • The T-score in the bone density (BMD) report depicts the variation of your bone mass from that of an average healthy 30-year-old adult. A T-score is a “standard deviation” — a mathematical calculation that’s calculates the variation of your result from the average or mean. The T score that you get from your bone density (BMD or DXA) test is measured as a standard deviation from the mean.

PREVENTION & SCREENING:

  • Almost everyone develops some degree of osteoarthritis as we age from the day-to-day wear and tear from activities.

Prevention tips:

  1. Maintain a healthy weight
  2. Keep a check and control blood sugar
  3. Regular exercise:
    Aquatic or water exercise is beneficial only in the beginning and in obese people. Land-based aerobic and strengthening exercises have a long-lasting effect. All the beneficial effects that come with exercise vanish once it is discontinued.
  4. Protect joints from injury.

Screening for early identification of osteoarthritis

  • During routine checkups always discuss with your doctor for screening of arthritis. Check for:
    • Any history of restriction of movement of joints
    • Bone enlargement
    • Crepitus (the popping, clicking or crackling sound) felt during movements of joints
    • Age >50 years (routine examination of joints)
    • Tenderness and or swelling of joints
  • Screening questionnaires like the Early Osteoarthritis Questionnaire (EOAQ) which is used as a tool to assess knee osteoarthritis at initial stage.
  • Xray/MRI of joints in case of any suspicious symptoms or indications of early OA during routine preventive health checks

Can be primarily prevented by:

  1. Eat foods that keep the bones healthy: Get enough calcium, Vitamin D and protein from food.
    • low-fat dairy
    • green leafy vegetables
    • fish
    • fortified food and beverages
    • milk
    • grains
  2. Increase physical activity: Try weight-bearing exercises, including strength training, walking, dancing etc.
  3. Quit Smoking if you smoke
  4. Avoid/Limit alcohol intake
  5. If your vitamin D level is low, talk to your doctor about supplementation.
  6. Avoid activities that may cause a fracture
    • Exercise to improve balance and strength
    • Wear the right shoes to provide support and prevent slipping that may increase chances of a fracture
    • Be mindful of the possible side effects of the medications you maybe taking for high BP etc. that may cause dizziness and falls leading to fractures
  • Screening for early identification of osteoporosis
  • Maintain a record of history of falls in adulthood.
  • Perform BMD (DEXA SCAN/Bone Mineral Density)
    • In women ≥ 65 years and men ≥ 70 years.
    • In postmenopausal women and men 50–69 years
    • In postmenopausal women and men ≥ 50 years with a history of fracture in adulthood
    • It’s advisable to go to the same facility and get the scan on the same densitometry device for each screening to avoid/minimize errors.

THERAPIES FOR OSTEOARTHRITIS

  • Medical Therapy: Pain relief medications like nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) or intraarticular steroid injections
  • Physical Therapy: A therapist can assist with exercises to strengthen your joints and improve your mobility.
  • Occupational therapy: Helps you adapt your work environment or habits to manage the effects of arthritis.
  • Orthotics: Like braces, splints, or shoe inserts to help relieve stress and pressure on the damaged joints.
  • Joint surgery: A joint replacement to replace the damaged joints.

THERAPIES FOR OSTEOPOROSIS

  1. Medications:
    • Bisphosphonates are the most widely prescribed oral medications and can be taken only when prescribed the doctor.
    • Sometimes, injectable medication called Denosumab is also given as per the doctor’s advice.
    • Bone Building Medications:
  2. Hormonal Therapy

Citation:

  1. Professional, C. C. M. (n.d.). Osteoporosis. Cleveland Clinic. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/4443-osteoporosis
  2. The National Council on Aging. (n.d.). https://www.ncoa.org/article/osteoarthritis-vs-osteoporosis-what-are-th…
  3. Osteoarthritis Action Alliance. (2022, August 4). Resources - Osteoarthritis Action Alliance. https://oaaction.unc.edu/resource-library/" https://oaaction.unc.edu/resource-library/
  4. Strickland, S. (2023). American Bone Health | Osteoporosis Education and Awareness. American Bone Health. http://www.americanbonehealth.org/
  5. Website, N. (2022, October 14). Causes. nhs.uk. https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/osteoporosis/causes/
  6. LeBoff, M. S., Greenspan, S. L., Insogna, K., Lewiecki, E. M., Saag, K. G., Singer, A., & Siris, E. S. (2022). The clinician’s guide to prevention and treatment of osteoporosis. Osteoporosis International, 33(10), 2049–2102. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00198-021-05900-y
  7. Osteoporosis. (n.d.). National Institute on Aging. https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/osteoporosis#keep
  8. Migliore, A., Алексеева, Л. И., Avasthi, S., Bannuru, R. R., Chevalier, X., Conrozier, T., Crimaldi, S., De Campos, G. C., Dıraçoğlu, D., Gigliucci, G., Herrero‐Beaumont, G., Iolascon, G., Ionescu, R., Jerosch, J., Laíns, J., Maheu, E., Makri, S., Мартусевич, Н. А., Matucci‐Cerinic, M., . . . Tarantino, U. (2023). Early Osteoarthritis Questionnaire (EOAQ): a tool to assess knee osteoarthritis at initial stage. Therapeutic Advances in Musculoskeletal Disease, 15, 1759720X2211316. https://doi.org/10.1177/1759720x221131604
  9. American Bone Health. (2022, January 28). Understanding Bone Density Results - Your T-score & Z-score Explained. American Bone Health. https://americanbonehealth.org/bone-density/understanding-the-bone-dens…

Stories

  • Stanford Medicine: Arts and Humanities in Medicine
    The world of medicine is beginning to increasingly acknowledge the potential of expressive arts therapies such as art, music, drama, dance/movement, poetry/creative writing and play in the context of healing, treatment, psychotherapy, counselling and rehabilitation. Activities such as drawing, drumming, creative movement and play acting allow individuals of all ages to express deep-seated thoughts and feelings, improve physical, mental and emotional well-being and boost self-esteem and…
  • Causes of Sciatica Pain and Prevention Tips
    Sciatica pain can cause extreme distress. This is a quick analysis of what causes it and 6 tips on how we can try and prevent it. Sciatica Sciatica pain is the pain and tingling caused by the sciatica nerve. It is usually felt as an intense pain in the leg and the pain travels all the way down from the spine. Sciatica is not a condition but a symptom itself that can have various underlying reasons. Causes of Sciatica pain: Injury or trauma: Direct injury to the spinal column can cause nerve…
  • Kathak Dance aids mobility of Parkinson’s and Arthritis patients
    Vonita Singh from Dubai is a trained Kathak dancer who, through her unique initiative Movement Mantra, addresses the basic concerns of Parkinson’s Disease like balance, flexibility and coordination with rhythm and music. Vonita also pulls in caregivers for her programmes, making it holistic, with end results being therapeutic. Taking on disorders like Parkinson’s Disease and Arthritis is a formidable task, especially when you are neither a therapist nor a medical person. What gave you the…
  • Household Tips to Ease Arthritis
    Dr S M Akerkar, Consulting Rheumatologist, offers some useful tips for people with arthritis to get work done at home the easier way and to minimize the load on the joints. This is the second of the 2-part series. In the first part we read useful day to day tips on arranging the kitchen to make it easier for people with arthritis to continue to function.  How to arrange your kitchen if you have arthritis? Use shelves with 'easy to remove' features. Drawers mounted on rollers put less…
  • Make your Kitchen Arthritis-Friendly
    Cooking can be a strenuous task for someone with arthritis and other muscle/joint disorders. But you don't have to give up cooking. Here are a few useful day to day tips to minimize the load on the joints and maximize what one can achieve in the kitchen, advises Dr S M Akerkar, Consulting Rheumatologist. This is the first of a 2-part series. The second part addresses the issue with visuals and examples. Your home and kitchen are supposed to be your most comfortable and familiar place in the…
  • A person at the gym lifting weight while looking at the mirror
    Perils of Body Weight Going Up and Down Rapidly
    When actors go through phases of rapid weight gain to rapid weight loss in preparation for film roles, many eyebrows are often raised among health professionals. Dr Shital Raval lists out reasons why it is medically dangerous and unhealthy of such yo-yoing. Imagine going from 68 kg to 93 kg in six months and then back again to original size. Well...That’s what actor Aamir Khan did recently oscillating from rapid weight gain to rapid weight loss. While Khan’s bulging - thinning programme…
  • Am I a Good Candidate for Hip or Knee Replacement?
    Who should have a Hip or Knee Replacement Surgery and what are the alternatives available? Dr Shital Raval suggests factors to help you make a decision.  Let us evaluate the various options available and the factors to consider. Arthroplasty Total hip replacement surgery is also known as Total Hip Arthroplasty while a knee replacement surgery is called Knee Arthroplasty (can be partial or total). Both are common and effective procedures for hip and knee arthritis. These are elective…
  • Where Being Different Is Unaccepted
    “Prejudice is the child of ignorance.” ― William Hazlitt ― In a diverse and informed society like Singapore, it remains not completely uncommon to hear of instances of discrimination. While it is understandable to fear or even condemn something that is strange or new to us, we should be reminded that understanding breeds tolerance and empathy. A Gift of Life Mr S, is a dialysis patient at the San Wang Wu Ti-KDF Centre at Kreta Ayer, and he has been dialysising there for slightly over a year. He…
  • Is UTI more common during Menopause?
    And other questions on menopause answered by Dr. Usha Saraiya,  Consultant Obstetrician – Gynaecologist at Breach Candy, Cumballa Hill Hospital & Saifee Hospital. She reiterates - Preventive actions helps to prevent Osteoporosis, diabetes & heart disease.  1.   What is the average age of menopause in India? It is between 45 years to 50 years. In India it is said to be earlier say from 42 years to 47 years. But women who are not educated do not tell their age…
  • Exercise to Improve Your Bone Health
    Neha Shah, fitness instructor, who was once immobile with rheumatoid arthritis, debunks the belief that exercise increases the risk of injury from broken bones for people with osteoporosis. On the contrary, she counsels that a regular, properly designed exercise program may actually help strengthen bones and muscles and improves balance, coordination and flexibility important for patients diagnosed with osteoporosis. Bones are the support system of our body. Bones are continuously being broken…