Skip to main content
Submitted by Dr S. Patel on 30 September 2016
A man clutching his heart having a heart attack

Heart diseases are the leading cause of death globally. Of these, about half the patients will undergo coronary angioplasty procedure at some time. Patients are then often faced with the choice of having a stent put in via angioplasty or going through a bypass surgery. So how do you make an informed decision with your doctor? Here are a few pertinent questions and answers by Dr. Shital Raval regarding the Stent vs Bypass dilemma.

These options should also be discussed with your doctor or Cardiologist.

What are the treatment options for heart disease?

Since heart disease is a chronic condition, management of cardiovascular disease on a daily basis is important. This will include taking prescribed medication on time, watching one’s diet, some form of daily exercise, loss of excess weight, reducing alcohol and tobacco usage and avoiding stress. Watching out for any usual signs and symptoms of a heart failure and getting tests conducted regularly is imperative.

What is a stent?

A stent is a tiny tube made of wire mesh that fits into any blood vessel. It then provides support for the damaged vessel wall while keeping it open for improved passage of blood. The aim is to prevent narrowing of the arteries and reducing the chances of re-stenosis (re-closing).

Pic credit:secondscount.org

In recent years, newer stents with drug eluting abilities have been developed. These stents are coated with medications that prevent scar tissue formation at the site of the stent insertion and reduce chances of re-stenosis.

What does the angioplasty procedure entail?

Angioplasty can be offered to patients with up to 3 narrowed arteries as long as the arteries are suitable for stenting. A balloon catheter is inserted via an artery till it reaches the section of the artery that needs to be widened.  The balloon is then inflated causing forced widening. This procedure is usually done for patient with atherosclerosis. Coronary stenting often accompanies the angioplasty procedure. Patients are usually put on blood thinners for a month along with aspirin to prevent any clot formation on the stent.

What is coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery?

As the name ‘bypass’ suggests, a detour is needed to be made around the blocked arteries. The surgeon commonly uses an artery or vein to create this bypass.  Normally a portion of a healthy vessel from the leg, chest or arm is used.

Pic credit:Commons Wikimedia

The minimally invasive approach to conventional CABG is called MIDCAB or minimally invasive direct coronary artery bypass. Here, the surgeon does not cut through the sternum or use the heart-lung machine. Few incisions are made between ribs for easy access to the arteries. This makes the surgery less traumatic and reduces the hospital stay and recovery time. Patients with no more than 2 blocked arteries are eligible for MIDCAB.

When is CABG offered over stenting?

Patients who have blockage or narrowing in their left main coronary artery or with more than 2 blocked arteries are generally asked to consider bypass surgery. Additionally, for patients with diabetes or heart failure, a heart bypass is recommended as it has better survival outcomes.

Related Reading: Understanding the maze of cardiac tests

What is the recovery time for both?

Since angioplasty is commonly done on patients with a less severe artery disease, and is a minimally invasive procedure, the recovery time is also faster. Complete recovery from a traditional CABG may take 6 to 12 weeks. For MIDCAB, this time is much less.

How many such procedures does the hospital or the doctor perform annually?

This question matters because the experience of the doctor and hospital in managing such procedures matters. Additionally most cardiologists do boast of performing upward of 100 plus procedures a year. Also, past records and speaking to patients who have undergone the procedure may be helpful in coming to a decision.

Why is one offered over the other?

It is always best to directly ask your Cardiologist why one procedure was offered over the other. He or she may be the best person to answer why he/she believes what is most suitable for you. Your doctor will discuss the decision-making process which relies on your overall health, severity of the heart disease, other conditions (like diabetes, lung diseases, heart valve problems, etc), factors such as age or low immunity etc. Make sure your doctor is aware of your complete medical history and can evaluate all the factors. New research studies and findings can also impact the ever-evolving treatment practices. Speak to your doctor about what’s right for YOU. If you are uncertain or uncomfortable with your options, seek a second opinion.

 

References:

1.    Angioplasty Versus Bypass Surgery for Coronary Artery Disease. Andrew D. Michaels and Kanu Chatterjee. Circulation. 2002;106:e187-e190, published online before print December 3, 2002

2.    https://www.secondscount.org/treatments/treatments-detail-2/questions-to-ask-your-doctor-about-undergoing-angi-2#.V7xAfFR96hc

3.    https://www.bhf.org.uk/heart-matters-magazine/medical/heart-bypass-surgery/cabg-vs-angioplasty

4.    https://www.verywell.com/stents-or-bypass-surgery-1745725

 

Stories

  • First-Aid for Cardiac Arrest
    Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) is one of the leading causes of death and disability worldwide. Quick and fast intervention helps. Dr. Shital Raval recommends first aid tips for cardiac arrest. Sudden cardiac arrest occurs when the heart stops beating suddenly commonly due to some electrical malfunction. The victim becomes unresponsive, unconscious with no signs of breathing or movement. Death can occur within minutes as blood stops flowing to the lungs, brain and other…
  • Image of Papads or Popaddams to show an unhealthy snack
    4 Popular Unhealthy Snacks You Really Should Limit
    Meenu Agarwal, a clinical dietitian and nutritionist based in Singapore, advises on controlling consumption of junk food to stay fit and free from ailments like diabetes, cholesterol, acidity, hypertension and other complications and offers healthier options. Junk food is defined as “any food, which is low in essential nutrients and high in everything else - calories and sodium". Junk foods contain little or no proteins, vitamins or minerals but are rich in salt, sugar, fats and are high in…
  • A woman outdoors in tights and running shoes holding her calf
    Leg Cramps - Causes and Prevention Tips
    Do you sometimes get sudden cramps in your calf or toe muscles? Dr. Shital Raval explains the causes and tips to get rid of leg cramps and to prevent them  Leg cramps or Charley horse (term used mainly in Canada and the US) is a common but harmless condition experienced by most individuals. These are sudden painful contractions of the leg muscles often in the calf area. They can last for seconds to a few minutes and rarely last more than 10 minutes. हिंदी में पढ़ें: पैर में ऐंठन -…
  • Do You Need the Serum Chloride Test?
    This time in our Health by Numbers/Medical Tests series, Dr Shital Raval takes a look at the importance of Chloride levels in the electrolyte panel. Read the first part on Sodium Levels and second part on Potassium Levels An electrolyte panel is a blood test that measures the common minerals in the body such as sodium, calcium, chloride, magnesium, phosphorous, and potassium. Electrolytes are essential for the proper functioning of the heart, muscles and brain as they are needed to…
  • Smoking Causes Early Death Among 50% of its Users
    Dr Prakash C. Gupta, Director of Healis-Sekhsaria Institute of Public Health, has researched public health in India extensively over decades and shares with us his valuable opinions on tobacco use and cessation. Scroll down to sign the pledge The Age when it all begins Even when it may be difficult to ascertain the age in which people start smoking, the mean age of initiating tobacco use in any form in India is determined at 17.8 years: 18 for males, 17.1 for females. For smoking, it is 17.9 (…
  • Physical Activity and Exercise Can Help Keep Mental Illness in Control
    Exercise and yoga can improve quality of life for people with mental illness and reduce risks of strokes, diabetes, auditory hallucinations and other health problems, informs Dr R Padmavati, Additional Director, Schizophrenia Research Foundation. World Health Organisation defines physical activity as any bodily movement produced by skeletal muscles that requires energy expenditure. Physical activity is not just "exercise". Exercise, is a subcategory of physical activity that is planned,…
  • Together, We are Able to Overcome Rejections and Obstacles
    Preethi Srinivasan was a young and energetic achiever in every sense of the word, till an accident made her a quadriplegic overnight. On Mother’s Day, Preethi’s mother Vijayalakshmi Srinivasan talks about what it means to be a mother and a friend to her daughter and to ensure her daughter always feels loved and cared for. From being a mother of a super achiever child to suddenly having to cope with the child's disability, what were your first thoughts and feelings? On the day of her accident,…
  • How to Stay Healthy after Menopause
    Post-Menopause is tied to long-term health problems if wholesome food intake and regular physical activity is not practiced. Nutritionist Kohila Govindaraju shares tips on what to eat and importance of exercise. Menopause is a natural biological process. It is the time when a woman stops menstruating. The hormones estrogen and progesterone production will be low and the ovaries no longer produce eggs. In women, estrogen is mainly produced in the ovaries. It is also produced in fat cells and…
  • White Meat vs Red Meat: Which is Healthier?
    Is it true that red meat should be avoided, while white meat encouraged? Bonnie Lau, an Australian-trained dietitian, counselling patients on GlycoLeap, answers. Here, we compare the pros and cons of both and helps you decide which type of meat you should eat in the future. Meat is a great source of protein and lots of vitamins and minerals. But there are claims that red meat (mutton, lamb, beef, pork) should generally be avoided, while white meat (chicken, duck, fish) is encouraged. We look at…
  • What do the numbers on your blood report mean?
    You have the Complete Blood Test in front of you and don’t now what the results mean. Dr. Shital Raval explains it in simple terms in our Health by Numbers/Medical Tests series. A CBC or complete blood test is a basic blood test which is often carried out along with a physical examination to verify and analyse various cellular components in the blood. This allows the doctor to check and confirm any suspicions and find any potential health problems. CBC test result alone may not be sufficient to…