Stents or Bypass Surgery – Which Works Better?

Submitted by Dr S. Patel on 30 September 2016
A man clutching his heart having a heart attack

Heart diseases are the leading cause of death globally. Of these, about half the patients will undergo coronary angioplasty procedure at some time. Patients are then often faced with the choice of having a stent put in via angioplasty or going through a bypass surgery. So how do you make an informed decision with your doctor? Here are a few pertinent questions and answers by Dr. Shital Raval regarding the Stent vs Bypass dilemma.

These options should also be discussed with your doctor or Cardiologist.

What are the treatment options for heart disease?

Since heart disease is a chronic condition, management of cardiovascular disease on a daily basis is important. This will include taking prescribed medication on time, watching one’s diet, some form of daily exercise, loss of excess weight, reducing alcohol and tobacco usage and avoiding stress. Watching out for any usual signs and symptoms of a heart failure and getting tests conducted regularly is imperative.

What is a stent?

A stent is a tiny tube made of wire mesh that fits into any blood vessel. It then provides support for the damaged vessel wall while keeping it open for improved passage of blood. The aim is to prevent narrowing of the arteries and reducing the chances of re-stenosis (re-closing).

Pic credit:secondscount.org

In recent years, newer stents with drug eluting abilities have been developed. These stents are coated with medications that prevent scar tissue formation at the site of the stent insertion and reduce chances of re-stenosis.

What does the angioplasty procedure entail?

Angioplasty can be offered to patients with up to 3 narrowed arteries as long as the arteries are suitable for stenting. A balloon catheter is inserted via an artery till it reaches the section of the artery that needs to be widened.  The balloon is then inflated causing forced widening. This procedure is usually done for patient with atherosclerosis. Coronary stenting often accompanies the angioplasty procedure. Patients are usually put on blood thinners for a month along with aspirin to prevent any clot formation on the stent.

What is coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery?

As the name ‘bypass’ suggests, a detour is needed to be made around the blocked arteries. The surgeon commonly uses an artery or vein to create this bypass.  Normally a portion of a healthy vessel from the leg, chest or arm is used.

Pic credit:Commons Wikimedia

The minimally invasive approach to conventional CABG is called MIDCAB or minimally invasive direct coronary artery bypass. Here, the surgeon does not cut through the sternum or use the heart-lung machine. Few incisions are made between ribs for easy access to the arteries. This makes the surgery less traumatic and reduces the hospital stay and recovery time. Patients with no more than 2 blocked arteries are eligible for MIDCAB.

When is CABG offered over stenting?

Patients who have blockage or narrowing in their left main coronary artery or with more than 2 blocked arteries are generally asked to consider bypass surgery. Additionally, for patients with diabetes or heart failure, a heart bypass is recommended as it has better survival outcomes.

Related Reading: Understanding the maze of cardiac tests

What is the recovery time for both?

Since angioplasty is commonly done on patients with a less severe artery disease, and is a minimally invasive procedure, the recovery time is also faster. Complete recovery from a traditional CABG may take 6 to 12 weeks. For MIDCAB, this time is much less.

How many such procedures does the hospital or the doctor perform annually?

This question matters because the experience of the doctor and hospital in managing such procedures matters. Additionally most cardiologists do boast of performing upward of 100 plus procedures a year. Also, past records and speaking to patients who have undergone the procedure may be helpful in coming to a decision.

Why is one offered over the other?

It is always best to directly ask your Cardiologist why one procedure was offered over the other. He or she may be the best person to answer why he/she believes what is most suitable for you. Your doctor will discuss the decision-making process which relies on your overall health, severity of the heart disease, other conditions (like diabetes, lung diseases, heart valve problems, etc), factors such as age or low immunity etc. Make sure your doctor is aware of your complete medical history and can evaluate all the factors. New research studies and findings can also impact the ever-evolving treatment practices. Speak to your doctor about what’s right for YOU. If you are uncertain or uncomfortable with your options, seek a second opinion.

 

References:

1.    Angioplasty Versus Bypass Surgery for Coronary Artery Disease. Andrew D. Michaels and Kanu Chatterjee. Circulation. 2002;106:e187-e190, published online before print December 3, 2002

2.    https://www.secondscount.org/treatments/treatments-detail-2/questions-to-ask-your-doctor-about-undergoing-angi-2#.V7xAfFR96hc

3.    https://www.bhf.org.uk/heart-matters-magazine/medical/heart-bypass-surgery/cabg-vs-angioplasty

4.    https://www.verywell.com/stents-or-bypass-surgery-1745725

 

Community
Heart and Cardio-vascular
Condition
Cardiovascular Diseases

Stories

  • High blood pressure in women 'more dangerous' than in men
    New research suggests that women with high blood pressure are at higher risk than their male counterparts, prompting researchers to recommend different treatments in women. http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/270747.php
  • Cardiovascular Diseases
    is a term that refers to different problems or disorders affecting the heart. In Asian countries, heart disease has become increasingly prevalent in recent decades and now accounts for about one third of all deaths. This is mainly because of changing lifestyles – people eat foods with higher energy and fat and lead more sedentary lives.  Causes and Risk factors : http://www.patientsengage.com/conditions/cardiovascular-diseases/causes-risk-factors Signs and Symptoms…
  • Medication and meditation
    High cholesterol and heart trouble ran in her family. But Varsha Marfatia, 85, didn’t let it control her life, says her grand-daughter Utsa Shah.  Tell us about your grandmother’s condition.  She had high cholesterol leading to angioplasty.  When was she diagnosed? She was diagnosed with high cholesterol in 1974 when she was 44. She had developed yellow deposits under her eye. She was tested and immediately put on medication. Initially her cholesterol levels were…
  • Salt to taste
    Just as too much salt leads to health problems, so does too little. How much is just right? Hear it from Dr Gita Mathai, paediatrician and family practitioner. Salt was a precious commodity in historical times. The word “salary” is derived from “salt” and Roman soldiers were paid partly in salt. Valuable employees were described as “the salt of the earth” and dispensable ones as “salt that had lost its flavour.” Somewhere between the Roman era and the 21st century…
  • Carbs are not your enemy!
    With all the hype around high-protein diets, more and more people want to cut down, and some want to eliminate, carbohydrates from their diets. But not only are carbohydrates present in almost all foods, eliminating them would disturb the body’s natural functioning, says Dietitian and Diabetes Educator Ujjwala Baxi. Why do we need carbohydrates? Carbohydrates are the body’s primary source of fuel for our internal and external functions. Carbohydrates are digested and broken down into glucose,…
  • Fish Lasagna (6 Portions)
    Lasagna made from whole wheat doesn’t spike the post-lunch blood sugar as much as the refined flour varieties. Tuna rich in omega- 3 fatty acids and Vitamin D are ideal for people with diabetes who run a higher risk of cardiovascular problems, high blood pressure and elevated triglycerides.  Ingredients: Tuna /White Pomfret (boneless ) - 700 g Onion – 2 Olive oil – 2 tbsp Tomato puree – 1 cup or 250g Sundried tomatoes - 10 g Freshly ground pepper - ¼ tsp Sweet corn - 300g…
  • Chicken roast with apple sauce (6 portions)
    This preparation is a low-calorie modification of the typical roast. The initial tossing in oil reduces the chicken from drying out while in the oven. The apple sauce without sugar is highly recommended for those who wish to keep their sugar spikes under control after the meal. Ingredients  Whole dressed chicken – 1 ½ kg 4 apples 6-8 small onions 6 potatoes 4-5 carrots 20 French beans 1 capsicum 1 tsp ginger juice 1 tbsp soy sauce (optional) 2 tbsp Worcester sauce 1 stick cinnamon 10 to12…
  • Avocado In Lettuce Boats (6 servings)
    Elevated levels of blood sugar in diabetes increase the risk of elevated ‘bad’ cholesterol, triglycerides and other cardiovascular problems. Attempts to reduce these risk factors through medication and diet also reduce the level of ‘good’ cholesterol. Exercise and the presence of moderate amounts of monounsaturated fats in the diet help to increase ‘good’ cholesterol in our body. Avocado, also called “butter fruit” in some parts of India, is rich in monounsaturated fats and anti-oxidant Vitamin…