Is Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson's recommended or not?

Submitted by PatientsEngage on 24 June 2016

Dr. Pettarusp Wadia Consultant Neurologist and Movement Disorder Specialist, Jaslok Hospital and Research Centre, Mumbai weighs in on when Deep Brain Stimulation treatment for Parkinson's Disease is a recommended choice and what factors you should consider before making a decision. 

Deep Brain Stimulation(DBS) in Parkinson's disease is recommended when 

  1. The patient has a confirmed diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease –
    • fits UKPDS brain bank criteria
    • The patient should ideally be at least 4-5 years in his/her illness to exclude the possibility of missing other disorder which may mimic Parkinson's disease in the early stages.
  2. The quality of life of a patient is affected despite best medical care.
  3. The disabling symptoms improve with L DOPA (Syndopa or Sinemet). The best ON response determines the benefit from DBS

Here is a case study of Hari who underwent DBS treatment for his Parkinson's Disease

When is DBS not recommended?

1. Very old patients – usually 75 and above for STN DBS

2. Significant cognitive issues – i.e. significant memory impairment

3. Significant psychiatric issues especially depression

4. Symptoms that do not respond to L Dopa (Syndopa or Sinemet) which are the reason to consider DBS

What factors would help a family decide if its appropriate for the patient in their family

  1. Disease duration
  2. Confirmed diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease
  3. Response to L Dopa
  4. Poor quality of life despite adequate medical treatment
  5. Good cognition
  6. Absence of significant psychiatric issues
  7. Lastly the DECISION if the patient is a candidate for surgery should be taken by the NEUROLOGIST after appropriate evaluation rather than the neurosurgeon.

What skill sets should the family look for

  1. A centre with experience in performing DBS
  2. That has a team with a trained stereotactic or functional neurosurgeon
  3. A trained movement disorder neurologist on the team

Is DBS the same as Stem Cell Therapy?

No – DBS involved stimulating the brain using electrodes implanted in the brain. 

Stem cells are cells which are aimed to produce dopamine in the brain – however this is still in research and not recommended for clinical use.

Stem cell therapy is NOT APPROVED FOR CLINCAL USE. It is only a research tool.

Is DBS more advanced and safe?

Deep brain stimulation surgery has completed more than 20 years in the world. It is approved by all regulatory authorities across the world and there is CLASS 1 evidence to recommend the same to the above subset of patients.

DBS is not without its share of risks. There are risks primarily that if an infection or a risk of brain haemorrhage when implanting the electrodes.

  

Rigorous exercise may slow Parkinson's Disease progression

 

Community
Neurological Conditions
Parkinsons Disease and Movement Disorder PDMDS
Condition
Parkinson Disease

Stories

  • A young woman with short dark hair on the right supporting and looking at an elderly silver haired woman on the left
    Preventing Caregiver Burnout While Caring For Person With Parkinson's
    Taking care of a person with Parkinson’s is tough and it progressively gets tougher as the condition progresses. Samiksha Sivan, Clinical Psychologist, PDMDS talks about caregiver burnout and how a caregiver can take of herself/himself.  “It is extremely tough to see my husband, who was such a lively person become so dull and expressionless. I help him with most of his everyday tasks now and he seems to realise somewhere that he is dependent on me and he hates it! I worry a…
  • Two juxtaposed images of Parkinsons Patient Mr Zend Merwan Zend in a light shirt
    Humans Of Parkinsons story - Mr. Zend Merwan Zend
    A grandchild remembers grandpa Zend Merwan Zend and how the progression of  Parkinson's Disease affected the man, his activities of daily living but not his zest and will power for life. Zend The Boxer (1948) Zend The Baker (1950) Zend the Marathoner (2012-2013)  Zend The Conqueror (Afternoon newspaper 26-7-12) The above titles are what Zend Merwan Zend (Born :9-12-1935) is known by. I simply call him Grandpa!  At the age of 60, my grandfather (I hero worship him) had suddenly…
  • Image: Black and white pic of Marianne's parents as a young couple - mom on the left and dad on the right
    Parkinson’s Robbed Their Soul And Spirit
    Marianne de Nazareth recounts how traumatic it has been to see both her parents suffer from Parkinson’s and how the progressive disease strips the dignity of the individual. Parkinson’s is an old disease in our house. Both my Dad and Mom were afflicted with it, unfortunately.  My Dad was ravaged by it first, and now it is after my Mom. It has been tormenting our family for nearly three decades now. My father, Anthony Michael Furtado, got Parkinson’s in his mid-50s. We started noticing a…
  • Image of an older silver haired person thinking and a younger dark haired person in a blue shirt and white t-shirt sitting next to him and debating whether to share or not about Parkinson's Disease diagnosis
    To Share or Not to Share - A Patient’s Dilemma
    Rajeev, 56 has been diagnosed with Parkinson's Disease but is unsure of the reaction he will receive if he shares his diagnosis of Parkinson's with his social circle. What do you think he should do?  Living in Dread “Hey, WHAT happened to you? Are you all right?”, screamed my cousin Sony who met me after several years at a wedding. Gosh! The secret is out, I thought. “I am all right, why?”, I said, keeping up the charade. “You are too slow”, he was spot on.  Sony is a doctor and he…
  • Mr Dugar, bespectacled man with black hair holding a mike sharing tips on improving quality of life with Parkinsons
    "If I Can Change, So Can Others"
    Sudha Meiyappan, founder of Parivarthan, shares Mr. Sagarmal Dugar's conscious approach to Parkinson's and to his life.  Parivarthan is a community support group in Chennai that provides a safe platform to those diagnosed with Parkinson’s disorder.  There are few people who are so inspiring that each interaction with them leaves one with a feeling of lightness and hope.  Mr. Sagarmal Dugar (holding the mike in the picture above) approached us in early 2016 wanting to be…
  • Recognizing Non-Motor Symptoms of Parkinson’s
    The lesser known non-motor, psychological symptoms of Parkinson’s disease such as depression and anxiety can be more difficult to manage and more disabling than the characteristic motor problems like tremors and rigidity. Learn more about it from psychologist Meghana Srinivasan from Parkinson’s Disease and Movement Disorder Society (PDMDS). Parkinson’s disease is primarily known to be a neurological disorder that is mainly characterised by problems in body movements that affect daily…
  • Image: Stock pic of an older silver haired woman in a blue sweater sitting on a sofa and holding hands for an article on living well with Parkinsons Disease
    Keys To Living Better With Parkinson's Disease
    Dr Kapil Agarwal, Senior Consultant & HOD Department of Neurology at W Pratiksha Hospital in Gurgaon, discusses some salient issues about Parkinson’s Disease and how one can tackle it best. Symptoms of Parkinson’s Disease Following symptoms may indicate that patient may be suffering from Parkinson's disease: Tremors of hands, head, body, etc. Slowing of movements in routine activities like walking, eating, dressing, bathing, etc. Reduction of facial expressions- decreased blinking of eyes…
  • Image; Shaila Bhagwat, who has Parkinson's Disease in a blue dress at a restaurant with plates of desserts in front of her
    I Am Doing All I Can To Avoid Being Bedridden
    Shaila Bhagwat, 67 has Parkinson's which affects her right-side. She makes every effort to remain independent and self-reliant with an assorted and strict regimen of exercises, yoga, meditation, laughter and music therapy, gait training, handwriting practice, knowledge building, among other resolutions. Four years ago, I had a tendon tear in the right shoulder and had a suture anchor inserted. It took me 2 months to recover from my surgery with the help of physiotherapy. But unfortunately, as…
  • Image: Mr. Ramesh Thakkar who Has Parkinson's Disease with a spectacle framing his face and seated in a room
    I Fought Hard to Save my Voice
    Sometimes willpower can knock out even health adversities. As in the case of 72-year-old Rajendra M Thakkar, retired General Manager of Reserve Bank of India, who straightened out his speech impairment, a symptom of Parkinson’s, through sheer grit and diligent exercises. When my Parkinson’s set in a few years back, I was in the midst of cardiological issues and bypass surgery, and didn’t pay much attention to the mild trembling of my hands and legs. But when my speech started getting affected…
  • Image: A man facing the camera in a green outdoor setting, wearing sunglasses, travelling after Deep Brain Stimulation surgery
    Belief In The Process And Faith In The Doctors Helped Me Overcome My Fear
    Mr Hari Prasad, who underwent the Deep Brain Stimulation operation about 3 years back to stall growing symptoms of Parkinson’s Disease, is a happy and relaxed person today, sharing his views on PD and DBS. Hari, how many years has it been since you had the DBS operation? Exactly three years. (Operation done end of March 2015) Read how Hari stopped popping pills for Parkinson's Disease every 2 hours  Has it been smooth for you since you had the operation? More or less. There has been no…

Latest Stories

Booklet