Is Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson's recommended or not?

Submitted by PatientsEngage on 24 June 2016

Dr. Pettarusp Wadia Consultant Neurologist and Movement Disorder Specialist, Jaslok Hospital and Research Centre, Mumbai weighs in on when Deep Brain Stimulation treatment for Parkinson's Disease is a recommended choice and what factors you should consider before making a decision. 

Deep Brain Stimulation(DBS) in Parkinson's disease is recommended when 

  1. The patient has a confirmed diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease –
    • fits UKPDS brain bank criteria
    • The patient should ideally be at least 4-5 years in his/her illness to exclude the possibility of missing other disorder which may mimic Parkinson's disease in the early stages.
  2. The quality of life of a patient is affected despite best medical care.
  3. The disabling symptoms improve with L DOPA (Syndopa or Sinemet). The best ON response determines the benefit from DBS

Here is a case study of Hari who underwent DBS treatment for his Parkinson's Disease

When is DBS not recommended?

1. Very old patients – usually 75 and above for STN DBS

2. Significant cognitive issues – i.e. significant memory impairment

3. Significant psychiatric issues especially depression

4. Symptoms that do not respond to L Dopa (Syndopa or Sinemet) which are the reason to consider DBS

What factors would help a family decide if its appropriate for the patient in their family

  1. Disease duration
  2. Confirmed diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease
  3. Response to L Dopa
  4. Poor quality of life despite adequate medical treatment
  5. Good cognition
  6. Absence of significant psychiatric issues
  7. Lastly the DECISION if the patient is a candidate for surgery should be taken by the NEUROLOGIST after appropriate evaluation rather than the neurosurgeon.

What skill sets should the family look for

  1. A centre with experience in performing DBS
  2. That has a team with a trained stereotactic or functional neurosurgeon
  3. A trained movement disorder neurologist on the team

Is DBS the same as Stem Cell Therapy?

No – DBS involved stimulating the brain using electrodes implanted in the brain. 

Stem cells are cells which are aimed to produce dopamine in the brain – however this is still in research and not recommended for clinical use.

Stem cell therapy is NOT APPROVED FOR CLINCAL USE. It is only a research tool.

Is DBS more advanced and safe?

Deep brain stimulation surgery has completed more than 20 years in the world. It is approved by all regulatory authorities across the world and there is CLASS 1 evidence to recommend the same to the above subset of patients.

DBS is not without its share of risks. There are risks primarily that if an infection or a risk of brain haemorrhage when implanting the electrodes.

  

Rigorous exercise may slow Parkinson's Disease progression

 

Community
Neurological Conditions
Parkinsons Disease and Movement Disorder PDMDS
Condition
Parkinson Disease

Stories

  • Unite for Parkinson's
    WORLD PARKINSON'S DAY It is 200 years since Parkinson's disease was first identified. Here are some inspiring thoughts from our friends at Humans of Parkinson's. We're joining in the conversation and uniting for Parkinson's, because 200 years is too long. People with Parkinson's share their experiences, what empowers them and what keeps them going.     If you have an experience to share, please leave us a comment below. #UniteforParkinsons #MyExperienceMatters    …
  • Tips on Staying Active & Complementary Therapies for people with Dementia
    There are a lot of things you can do especially in the early to middle stages to manage and delay the progression of dementia. Read on to find out more: Staying Active Finding activities that the person with AD can do and is interested in can be a challenge. Building on current skills generally works better than trying to teach something new.  Don't expect too much. Simple activities are best, especially when they use current abilities. Help the person get started on an activity. Break…
  • Caregiver Tips on Bathing, Dressing and Eating for a person with Dementia
    Sometimes the Daily activties like Bathing, Dressing and Eating can be a huge challenge for caregivers looking after a person with dementia. Here are a few useful tips. Let us know which one you find helpful. Tips for Bathing For some people bath time can be a frightening, confusing experience.  Plan the bath or shower for the time of day when the person is most calm and agreeable. Be consistent. Try to develop a routine. Tell the person what you are going to do, step by step, and allow…
  • Stanford Medicine: Arts and Humanities in Medicine
    The world of medicine is beginning to increasingly acknowledge the potential of expressive arts therapies such as art, music, drama, dance/movement, poetry/creative writing and play in the context of healing, treatment, psychotherapy, counselling and rehabilitation. Activities such as drawing, drumming, creative movement and play acting allow individuals of all ages to express deep-seated thoughts and feelings, improve physical, mental and emotional well-being and boost self-esteem and…
  • Dos and Don'ts of communicating with a person with Dementia
    Communicating with a person with dementia can be quite a challenge. There are some tips that can definitely help get the attention of the person and not agitate them. Here are some Dos and Don'ts. DO's DON'Ts Approach from the front, make eye contact and introduce yourself if necessary Don’t wave hand while talking as person’s attention could be distracted Speak slowly, calmly and use a friendly facial expression Don’t talk too fast or shout. Shouting out could have negative effect…
  • Simple Tips for Caregivers of Persons with Dementia!
    Tips for Caregivers Dementia is a general term for decline in a person's mental ability that is severe enough to interfere with his/her daily life. It may involvememory loss, difficulties with thinking, problem-solving or language. Dementia is progressive, which means the symptoms will gradually get worse. Even though most cases of dementia come from irreversible causes, there is still much that families can do to help their loved ones continue to function as well as possible for as…
  • Kathak Dance aids mobility of Parkinson’s and Arthritis patients
    Vonita Singh from Dubai is a trained Kathak dancer who, through her unique initiative Movement Mantra, addresses the basic concerns of Parkinson’s Disease like balance, flexibility and coordination with rhythm and music. Vonita also pulls in caregivers for her programmes, making it holistic, with end results being therapeutic. Taking on disorders like Parkinson’s Disease and Arthritis is a formidable task, especially when you are neither a therapist nor a medical person. What gave you the…
  • Household Tips to Ease Arthritis
    Dr S M Akerkar, Consulting Rheumatologist, offers some useful tips for people with arthritis to get work done at home the easier way and to minimize the load on the joints. This is the second of the 2-part series. In the first part we read useful day to day tips on arranging the kitchen to make it easier for people with arthritis to continue to function.  How to arrange your kitchen if you have arthritis? Use shelves with 'easy to remove' features. Drawers mounted on rollers put less…
  • Event : Living with Parkinson's
    We invite you to 'Living with Parkinson's' an event for people with Parkinson's and their caregivers.  Dance & Movement Therapy followed by tips on living with Parkinson's by eminent Neurologist Dr. Manoj Hunnur Date: 27th December, Tuesday Address: Prabodhankar thackeray multipurpose hall, A wing, 2nd floor, Borivali west Timing: 10.30am to 1.30pm  
  • My 3.5 Years of Journey with Parkinson’s!
    Gargi Ahluwalia is immensely grateful to the Support Group of Parkinson's Disease and Movement Disorder Society, (PDMDS), that helped her claim her independence over the debilitating disease. I started trembling from January 2013 when my husband was hospitalised. Four months later, when he passed away, my situation became worse. I thought it was due to stress, not realizing that it was more than that. I spoke to my family doctor and he said that I should see a Neurologist who specialized in…

Latest Stories

Booklet